We decided to stay at home for New Year's Eve last year, as the previous year we'd done a delicious yet overpriced dinner out and poorly timed concert (perfect music, awful crowd). It being New Year's eve and thus a "special occasion," I decided it would be a good idea to plan an overly ambitious meal. I also thought we could save money--and have more fun by having a hand in creating it--by cooking our own lavish meal where we would not be overcharged just because it was New Year's. In other words, even though it was just the two of us, preparing the meal became a tad stressful as I didn't want to screw up our "special" meal.
We started out well with a simple arugula salad with parmesan shavings and garlic croutons and my favorite simple lemon-olive oil-garlic dressing. However, I had also chosen to make a skatewing dish from the Dean and Deluca cookbook after having enjoyed it in a number of restaurants.
Fish is one of my weak areas when it comes to cooking. I tend to get paranoid that I'm undercooking it so then I overcook it. Couple that with the fact skatewing is a bit different from a more standard fish fillet. Skatewing is thin and flat and has a lot of delicate parts. I knew what these parts were called once upon a time (back when I chose the dish) and maybe someday I'll try again.... A skatewing fillet is very difficult to flip over without breaking (note to self, invest in a huge spatula) not to mention takes up a lot of space in a skillet--so I decided to cook each of our fishes in separate skillets on different burners at the same time. The skatewing was on a bed of cabbage. When I was reading through the recipe I was thinking, hey, that'll be a lot of white on one plate...so I decided to do red cabbage. The cooked red cabbage is pretty in its own way, but looked really strange on the plate under the skatewing which was already doing just fine with a nicely browned surface (in some places, a little too nicely browned) and a caper and tomato sauce on top. I am now doubly--quadruply--infinity plus one impressed with the skatewing I've had in restaurants, which didn't look scary and colorful and stayed all in one piece.
My next menu-planning mistake was lobster mashed potatoes. Frozen Maine lobster tails from Whole Foods? Turned out to be insanely expensive, but once I decided I wanted to try the dish, I had to have it, expense be damned, and I did not want to bargain shop for lobster tail at other stores. The lobster mashed potatoes recipe also called for tarragon. Upon eating them, I learned that I do not like tarragon. Another "incident" happened while the potatoes were cooking....the potatoes got a bit overboiled (attention drawn to cooking the other components of the meal) and became incredibly watery. My last-ditch solution--I was not about to be bested by humble potatoes and not so humble lobster tail--dig out an old box of instant mashed potato flakes I've had in my cupboard since I bought them on impulse one day--when I was still in college. I have a problem with throwing out food. So the potato dish--not that great. The lobster by itself was good enough but was overwhelmed and insulted by the moutain of potatoes--instant mashed potatoes--which, to be fair, wouldn't have been a mountain if the original actual potatoes didn't get drowned in cooking water. I found myself picking out the bits of lobster and cursing the bounty of potatoes, even though potatoes are pretty much my favorite food ever. A grim day for potatoes (and lobsters) indeed.
Mark made the dessert--a cherry-almond clafouti. It smelled like a creamy version of almond extract and tasted like a custardy cross between a cake and a pie. It was a tasty delight.